Showing posts with label paradox. Show all posts
Showing posts with label paradox. Show all posts

Monday, June 10, 2013

Newcomb's Paradox

Last week's paradox poll is a well established if not well known philosophical paradox called Newcomb's paradox. It's the self-referential paradox as it pertains to freewill, and supposedly it divides people evenly, with half of people thinking the smart decision is to pick both boxes and the other half thinking the smart decision is to pick box B. Three people commented on the post last week, with the result that one person chose both boxes and two people chose to open only box B. I also asked two software developers at work, and they each decided to open both boxes. Thus, so far I've seen a 3–2 split.

Each decision has a good argument in its favor. The argument to open both boxes goes something like this:

The Predictor has already made his prediction, and thus the content of Box B is already established—it can't be changed by your choice. Given that Box A contains $1,000 no matter what, you're really choosing whether you want an extra thousand dollars by choosing to open both boxes instead of Box B alone. Meanwhile, we can hope that the Predictor predicted you would open only Box B, in which case you'll also get $1,000,000, too, but you have no effect on that outcome.

Whereas, the argument for opening only box B goes something like this:

The Predictor is usually correct, so it's a mistake to give much, if any, weight to the outcomes where the Predictor is wrong. Thus, you probably won't end up with either $0 (you choose Box B alone but the Predictor predicts you would open both boxes) or $1,001,000 (you choose both boxes but the Predictor predicts Box B alone). Instead, you're really choosing between $1,000 (both boxes) and $1,000,000 (Box B only), so you should choose the bigger amount, which means choosing to open Box B only.

The crux of which argument seems right to you depends on how free you think your choice is. The both-boxes argument assumes a very free choice, whereby the Predictor is at best making a coin-toss guess because the Predictor can't foresee your choice. Whereas, the Box B argument assumes that your choice is causally linked with the Predictor's choice, and thus your choice is the effect of well foreseen causes. As for how it's possible for your choice to be causally linked as such, the fashionable answer today is: deterministic brain chemistry. Then assume the Predictor possesses a superbly accurate brain scanner.

I'm a Box B guy. Though I think of myself as being good at understanding other people's arguments, I can't understand how the both-boxes people discredit the prior evidence of the Predictor being correct so many times. Such evidence precludes the possibility of my choice being free. But some people's belief in freewill is so strong that even hypothetical counter-evidence doesn't change their minds. —The Predictor has been right 98% of the time? No big deal! He's just been lucky, that's all— All this reminds me of the saying, I'll believe it when I see it, which has got it backwards. For most of us, we see it when we believe it.

Monday, June 3, 2013

Paradox poll

Be sure to also check out Riddle #5, which has stalled for a lack of wild guessing.

Today's post is a paradox poll. While I favor one way to resolve the problem, I'm curious what other people think, so please comment below. There really are no wrong answers to this.

Here's the paradox. There are two boxes before you—call them A and B—and you have a choice either to (1) open both boxes or (2) open only box B. You keep whatever is in a box you open, so if you choose to open both boxes then you keep what's in both boxes and if you choose to open only box B then you keep what's in box B but forgo whatever is in box A. Also, you have to make your choice all at once; you can't open box B and then later decide to open A, too. If it helps, imagine you have write down your choice on a piece of paper and that someone else opens the box(es) for you based on what you wrote down. Good so far?

So what's in the boxes? Money or nothing. No matter what happens, box A will contain $1,000. As for what box B contains, that depends on another person who we'll call Bob. Bob will try to predict whether you'll open both boxes or only box B. If he predicts you'll open only box B then he'll add $1,000,000 to box B. If Bob predicts you'll open both boxes then he'll add nothing to box B. Below is the table.

A & B B only
A & B $1,000 $1,001,000
B only $0 $1,000,000

In the table above, you choose the row, and Bob, based on his prediction, will choose the column. You want Bob to predict that you'll open only box B. All else held equal, you would prefer to open both boxes.

Here's the twist. Suppose you've played this game many times already—though presumably for much smaller sums—and Bob has correctly predicted your choice every time.

What do you choose to open?